The White House
Matthew A. McIntosh noted "The White House is not merely a structure; it is a symbol made stone, a spatial embodiment of a nation’s evolving conception of authority, elegance, and restraint. Though its silhouette is instantly recognizable, the meanings encoded within its neoclassical columns, its carefully chosen site, and its subsequent renovations reveal a history layered with ambition, contradiction, and reinvention."
The White House is the product of a 1792 design competition, with the winner picked by President Washington. George Washington "insisted the house be large enough to command respect abroad and signify stability at home... The house was to be more than a dwelling; it was to be a stage upon which the presidency would be enacted." Truman "was conscious of the symbolic power of the White House, and committed to preserving that symbol" even when completely renovating its interior.
Irish-born architect James Hoban designed the original White House, which had a short life — only 14 years. During the war of 1812, British soldiers set fire to the house (and a number of other government buildings) in what is now described as the Burning of Washington. On August 24, 1814, during the War of 1812, British troops entered Washington, D.C. and burned the White House in retaliation for the American attack on York in Ontario, Canada. This was the only time since the Revolutionary War that a foreign power captured and occupied a United States capital.
The 1814 destruction struck not just a building but the image of the nation itself. The ruins exposed the vulnerability of American institutions. The building's destruction ultimately reinforced its symbolic significance. The burning was a humiliating defeat that struck at the symbolic heart of the country.
From those bitter ashes a resilient nation emerged stronger and more unified. The burning of Washington symbolized that the young nation built upon democracy and freedom was able to take a major world power head-on and come out victorious, as Washington was quickly rebuilt. Hoban would oversee the reconstruction, which was completed in 1817. Working with architect Benjamin Henry Latrobe, Hoban would later add the South and North Porticos in 1824 and 1829, respectively.
Since the early 1960s, each presidential administration has seen the White House as a kind of living museum, making changes to the decor and maintaining the building's structure and exterior, but making very limited alterations to the architecture and layout. In the early 1990s, the White House exterior was extensively refurbished, with some 40 layers of paint removed and the sandstone exterior repaired and repainted.
Although predating the formal Secretary's Standards and the NHPA (enacted in 1966), First Lady Jacqueline Kennedy's restoration project set a precedent for historic preservation at the White House and influenced later standards. She established the White House Fine Arts Committee and the White House Historical Association to restore interiors with authentic historic furnishings, decorative arts, and objects, emphasizing the building as a "living museum."
This aligned with future standards by retaining and repairing distinctive materials and features rather than replacing them, avoiding false historical recreations, and preserving the property's historic character. The project also prevented the demolition of historic homes in Lafayette Square, leading to its designation as a National Register Historic District in 1970. Her efforts culminated in Executive Order 11145 (March 7, 1964), establishing the permanent Committee for the Preservation of the White House to oversee ongoing preservation, which has guided subsequent projects in line with emerging standards.
Truman White House Reconstruction (1948–1952), predating the Secretary's Standards, exemplifies the "reconstruction" treatment by dismantling and rebuilding the interior while preserving the historic exterior walls and facade. Prompted by structural failures, the project gutted the interior, installed a new steel frame, updated utilities (plumbing, wiring, heating, and air conditioning), and added sub-basements, but retained original room configurations and reinstalled historic elements where possible.
This approach mirrored the standards' emphasis on reconstructing non-surviving portions based on documentary evidence, using new materials only where necessary, and protecting the property's historic character as a record of its time. Modern analyses often cite it as an early model for such treatments in federal properties.
Rose Garden Renovation (2020), overseen by First Lady Melania Trump, directly referenced the Secretary's Standards in its planning documents. The project rehabilitated the garden—originally designed in 1962 by Rachel Lambert Mellon under President Kennedy—by updating infrastructure (irrigation, drainage, lighting, and accessibility), refreshing plantings, and returning to the 1962 footprint while preserving key historic elements like the Kennedy-era saucer magnolias.
A Living Monument to Democracy
The White House stood as the residence and workplace of every U.S. president since John Adams in 1800. More than just a building, it represented the ideals of American democracy—a home for the people's elected leader, designed to project authority without the ostentatious displays of European monarchies.
Built in the neoclassical style between 1792 and 1800, the White House was conceived as a symbol of republican values. Unlike the palaces of Europe, with their gilded halls and extravagant ornamentation, America's executive mansion was intended to be elegant yet understated—a reflection of democratic ideals rather than royal pretension.
A Tradition of Personal Touches
Throughout history, each president has left their mark on the White House. These changes have ranged from subtle to significant, reflecting the personality and priorities of each administration. Presidents are traditionally given a $100,000 budget for redecoration upon taking office.
Theodore Roosevelt (1901-1909)
Added the West Wing and created the modern Oval Office configuration.
Harry Truman (1945-1953)
Oversaw a complete reconstruction of the White House interior when structural problems were discovered.
Jacqueline Kennedy (1961-1963)
Launched the first major restoration, treating the White House as a museum of American history and decorative arts.
Ronald Reagan (1981-1989)
Added personal touches including bronze saddles and a jar of Jelly Belly jelly beans on his desk.
Barack Obama (2009-2017)
Introduced a bust of Martin Luther King Jr. and maintained a bowl of apples in the Oval Office.
The Oval Office: Symbol of Presidential Power
The Oval Office, perhaps the most recognizable room in the world, has been the president's workspace since 1909. Its distinctive shape, neoclassical architecture, and carefully curated décor have traditionally projected an image of dignified authority derived from democratic legitimacy rather than material splendor.
— Robin Givhan, The Washington Post
Traditional Design Philosophy
Historically, the Oval Office has been decorated with restraint and elegance. Presidents have displayed portraits of historical figures they admired, meaningful artifacts, and personal mementos, but the overall aesthetic has remained relatively understated. The room's power came not from golden ornamentation but from its place in the American democratic tradition.
The Biden administration, for example, maintained a modest aesthetic with simple ivy on the mantle, generously spaced portraits, and minimal decorative elements. This restraint has been the norm throughout modern presidential history.
The Rose Garden: America's Garden
The White House Rose Garden is one of the most iconic outdoor spaces in American political life. Originally established in 1913 by First Lady Ellen Wilson, the garden has served as the backdrop for countless historic moments—from presidential announcements to international ceremonies, from press conferences to the famous turkey pardons.
The Kennedy Vision
The modern Rose Garden was redesigned in 1962 under President John F. Kennedy. Working with his wife Jackie Kennedy and renowned designer Rachel "Bunny" Mellon, Kennedy sought to create an outdoor space worthy of America's position on the world stage.
— Rachel "Bunny" Mellon, Rose Garden designer
The Kennedy-era design featured a central lawn surrounded by rose beds, crabapple trees, and carefully chosen plantings. The grass lawn became an essential feature, hosting formal events while maintaining the natural beauty of a garden setting.
Historic Moments in the Rose Garden
?? Tricia Nixon's Wedding (1971)
The first and only wedding of a president's daughter held in the Rose Garden.
? Pelé's Visit (1975)
The Brazilian soccer legend juggled balls on the Rose Garden lawn for President Ford.
?? Historic Treaty Signings
Countless international agreements and legislative signings have taken place here.
?? Presidential Announcements
Major policy announcements and press conferences for decades.
The 2025 Transformation
Upon returning to office in January 2025, President Donald Trump initiated the most dramatic aesthetic transformation of the White House in modern presidential history. The changes, centered on the Oval Office and Rose Garden, represent a fundamental departure from the traditional restraint that has characterized these spaces.
? The Gilding of the Oval Office
Starting in February 2025, the Oval Office underwent a remarkable transformation that critics have variously described as "a gilded rococo hellscape," "gaudy-awful," and reminiscent of the Palace of Versailles. The changes have been progressive, with new gold elements appearing almost weekly throughout 2025.
Gold Elements Added:
- Gold vermeil figurines displayed on the mantle (from President James Monroe's 1817 gilt service)
- Gold medallions covering the fireplace and running horizontally and vertically across walls
- Gilded cherubs nestled in pediments above doorways (shipped from Mar-a-Lago)
- Gold eagles supporting side tables
- Gilded Rococo mirrors on doors
- Gold trim along crown molding
- Gold-plated FIFA World Cup trophy behind the Resolute Desk (later replaced with actual trophy)
- "Trump 47" gold coasters on coffee tables
- Gold-wrapped remote control for the television
- Metallic-toned presidential seal on the ceiling
Trump reportedly brought in his personal "gold guy" from Mar-a-Lago—John Icart, a cabinetmaker from south Florida—who was flown to Washington on Air Force One to help install the custom-made gold finishes. The president personally oversaw the installation and has boasted about using "the highest quality 24 karat gold."
?? The Paving of the Rose Garden
In what may be the most controversial White House renovation in decades, Trump ordered the complete removal of the Rose Garden's historic grass lawn, replacing it with stone paving. Construction began in June 2025 and was completed by August 2025.
The Kennedy-era lawn—which had served as the centerpiece of the garden for over 60 years and hosted countless historic moments—was bulldozed and replaced with white paving stones laid on the diagonal. The new design mimics the patio at Trump's Mar-a-Lago resort in Palm Beach, Florida.
— President Donald Trump, explaining the Rose Garden renovation
Trump justified the dramatic change by explaining that wet grass was problematic for people in high heels during press conferences and events. The new stone surface features presidential seals at the corners and drainage systems covered with Stars and Stripes-motif grates.
The rose beds themselves were preserved, and Trump emphasized that "the roses stay" and "it's a rose garden." However, the fundamental character of the space—a garden with a natural lawn—has been permanently altered to resemble an outdoor ballroom or patio.
Additional White House Changes
- Presidential Walk of Fame: Added to the exterior featuring headshots of previous presidents
- 100-foot flagpoles: Installed on North and South lawns, personally funded by Trump
- $200 million ballroom: Planned for construction, modeled after the Mar-a-Lago ballroom and inspired by the Hall of Mirrors at Versailles
- Kennedy memorial tree removed: A large magnolia tree planted to commemorate John F. Kennedy Jr. was cut down and replaced with a smaller tree
The Controversy: Democracy vs. Dynasty
The 2025 White House transformation has sparked intense debate about presidential authority, taste, historical preservation, and the symbolic meaning of America's most iconic building. Critics and supporters have sharply divided opinions about what these changes represent.
Critical Perspectives
Design and Aesthetic Criticism:
- New York Magazine: Described the overall approach as "tacky and trollish"
- The New York Times: Called the Oval Office décor a "gilded rococo hellscape"
- The Washington Post: Described it as "gaudy-awful"
- Robin Givhan (Washington Post): Noted it represents "an elitist point of view that would look at the way he's decorated the Oval Office and say that it looks very nouveau riche"
- Tommy Landen (Interior Designer): "When you overload it and just keep adding more and more, it becomes overwhelming. It becomes gaudy and tacky"
?? The Versailles Comparison
Multiple scholars have drawn comparisons between Trump's decorating style and Louis XIV's Palace of Versailles. Trump himself has called "the look and feel of Louis XIV" his "favorite style." However, critics point out a deep irony in this affection.
The White House was deliberately designed as the antithesis of European palaces—a neoclassical structure representing republican values rather than monarchical excess. As one art historian noted, "He wants to give that illusion of success" through material splendor, but in doing so contradicts the fundamental democratic principles the White House was built to embody.
Concerns About Historical Preservation
??? Architectural Integrity
The White House was built in neoclassical style. Gold baroque ornamentation clashes with this architectural philosophy and the building's historical character.
?? Environmental Impact
Replacing a living, breathing garden with stone eliminates green space, reduces carbon absorption, and removes habitat for pollinators and wildlife.
???? Symbolic Meaning
The transformation from democratic restraint to palatial opulence raises questions about what message the White House should send about American values.
?? Historical Legacy
The Kennedy-era Rose Garden and the traditional Oval Office aesthetic were themselves part of American history, now permanently altered.
The Defense
Supporters of the changes argue that every president has the right to personalize their workspace, and that Trump's aesthetic preferences are simply different from his predecessors. White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt described the redecorated Oval Office as a "golden office for the golden age."
— Former White House official
The White House Historical Association has noted that controversial remodels are part of presidential tradition, pointing to past additions like the South Portico, North Portico, and Truman Balcony that were criticized at the time but are now considered iconic features.
Some view Trump's decorating style as "an exuberant celebration of success" rather than excess, and note that some of the gold pieces are historic items from the White House collection dating back to the early 19th century.
The Manufacturing Irony
Public Reaction
The changes have generated millions of social media impressions, with reactions ranging from shock and dismay to amusement and support. Petitions calling for the Rose Garden to be restored have circulated, echoing similar petitions from Melania Trump's 2020 Rose Garden renovation.
Musician Jack White posted a photo of the gilded Oval Office to Instagram with criticism, while historians and preservationists have expressed concern about the permanent nature of these alterations to spaces of such historical significance.
The Larger Question
Beyond matters of taste, the 2025 White House transformation raises fundamental questions: What should the "People's House" look like? Should it reflect the understated elegance of democratic ideals, or can it legitimately embody the personal aesthetic preferences of whoever holds office, regardless of how opulent?
Does covering the Oval Office in gold and paving over a historic garden represent personal expression, or does it symbolize a departure from the values the White House was built to represent? These questions will likely be debated by historians and citizens for years to come.
— Stewart D. McLaurin, White House Historical Association President
(Referring to past controversial additions that became beloved features)
Looking Forward
As Trump continues his second term, additional renovations remain planned or underway, including the $200 million ballroom inspired by Versailles and Mar-a-Lago. Future presidents will inherit these changes and face decisions about whether to preserve them, modify them, or return the spaces to their previous aesthetic.
The White House has always been a living building, evolving with each administration. However, the scale and nature of the 2025 transformation—from traditional restraint to gilded maximalism, from natural garden to stone patio—represents one of the most dramatic aesthetic shifts in the building's 225-year history.
Whether these changes will ultimately be viewed as a regrettable deviation or simply another chapter in the White House's long story of transformation remains to be seen. What is certain is that they have sparked a national conversation about taste, power, democracy, and what symbols America should project to the world.
|
NEWSLETTER
|
| Join the GlobalSecurity.org mailing list |
|
|
|
