Ankara Threatens Sanctions Against Iraqi Kurds Over Independence Vote
By Dorian Jones September 15, 2017
Turkish Prime Minister Binali Yildirim warned Friday that the Iraqi Kurdish plan to hold an independence referendum was a "grave mistake." Iraqi Kurdistan regional President Masoud Barzani has called for the referendum on September 25 in the semi-autonomous area.
Turkey, which borders the Iraqi Kurdish region, has strong ties with Barzani, but Ankara has been stepping up its pressure to call off the vote.
"There are 10 days left [to the referendum]. Therefore, I want to repeat our friendly call to Masoud Barzani: Correct this mistake while there is still time," Yildirim said Friday to supporters.
The warning was followed by Ankara's first direct threat.
"We don't want to impose sanctions, but, if we arrive at that point, there are steps that have been already planned that Turkey can take," Yildirim added.
The warning comes days after the Turkish foreign minister, Mevlut Cavusoglu, told the Kurds that they would "pay a price for the vote."
Ankara, with its own restive Kurdish minority, that mainly borders Iraqi Kurdistan, fears an independent Kurdish state could fuel similar secessionist demands. Those fears are heightened by the suspicion that Syrian Kurds on the Turkish border harbor the same independence ambitions.
Turkish fears over the referendum have created rare common ground across the country's deep political divide.
"Balkanization of the Middle East would bring instability," warned Ceyda Karan, a columnist with the Turkish opposition Cumhuriyet newspaper. "Borders are not drawn fairly in many parts of the world. The question of where to find fairness in redrawing them is unknown."
The United States and Iran also have voiced strong opposition to the independence vote, but Turkey arguably has the most leverage on the Iraqi Kurds. The Habur border gate on Turkey's frontier with Iraq is the main trade route to the outside world for Iraqi Kurdistan, while an oil pipeline to the Turkish Mediterranean port of Ceyhan provides a financial lifeline.
Sanctions could prove to be a double-edged sword.
"Habur does not only mean gate to Iraqi Kurdistan," said former senior Turkish diplomat Aydin Selcen, who set up Turkey's consulate in Iraqi Kurdistan's capital of Irbil. "Habur means gate to Iraq and, in today's terms, means gate to the Middle East as all border gates are closed with Syria. There is the oil pipeline; Iraqi Kurdistan oil, including Kirkuk oil, is being marketed to global markets through [the port city of] Ceyhan. That is a win, win for Ankara."
Financial considerations are not the only factors that Ankara has to consider. "Ankara is against it [the referendum], but on the other hand, Barzani is the best ally in the region. I think they are not that vocal when it comes to the referendum," said political scientist Cengiz Aktar.
Barzani in the past decade has developed a close relationship with Ankara, one built not only on lucrative trade, but on security cooperation.
Barzani has provided assistance to Ankara in Turkey's war against the Kurdish rebel group the PKK, which is waging a decades-long insurgency for greater minority rights in Turkey and has bases in Iraqi Kurdistan.
Turkish election politics could further restrict Ankara's room to maneuver. The Iraqi Kurdish independence referendum threatens to complicate Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan's re-election bid in 2019.
"I understand Mr. Erdogan is trying to balance the traditional Kurdish vote that goes with [Erdogan's] AK Party and [Turkish] nationalists," said former diplomat Selcen, who is now a regional analyst.
The Kurdish vote in Turkey traditionally accounts for about 10 percent of Erdogan's support – votes that could be crucial in what is predicted to be a closely fought presidential election.
Analyst Selcen suggests the solution to the political conundrum posed by the Iraqi Kurdish independence vote to Erdogan's own ambitions could be to simply do nothing.
"I think in today's system in Turkey, one should only follow closely what Mr. Erdogan says and, knowing his usual style and usual rhetoric, I find Mr. Erdogan's position much milder and more moderate. I will speculate that following September 25, the day of the referendum, it will be business as usual between Ankara and Irbil."
|Join the GlobalSecurity.org mailing list|