A Factual Report about the Implementation
of Iraq's Obligations Under para (C) of the
SC Resolution 687 (1991) In the Field of
Chemical Weapons Disarmament
1. The Special Commission started its activities in the chemical field in June 1991. Since then Iraq was keen to offer all kinds of cooperation in presenting all past chemical programme - related data. These data include all precursors, primary and produced chemical materials and all the relevant imported equipment as well as the filled and empty ammunition. Also, Iraq declared the sites of the past chemical programme. Iraq did so to implement its obligations under para ( C ) of the SC Resolution 687 (1991).
2. The Special Commission started its missions in September 1991 with the destruction of the empty chemical ammunition in Al-Muthana Establishment. 12500 items were destroyed (different air - bombs and artillery shells ).
3. In February 1992, the Special Commission destroyed (122mm Rocket ) Sarine - filled ammunitions in Al-Khamissyah. The destruction took place in this area in an agreement between the experts of the SC and the Iraqi side . No technical capability was available to destroy them in al-Muthana Establishment. The Iraqi side destroyed them under the supervision of the SC. (400) missiles were destroyed within (40) days. The Iraqi side showed full cooperation with the Special Commission. A reference was made to such cooperation in its reports.
4. The pieces destroyed by the Special Commission in al-Muthana Establishment within the period June 1992 - June 1994 involve:
A- Finally produced agents 690 tons.
B- Empty and filled ammunition 38537 pieces.
C- liquid precursors 180000 liters.
D- Solid precursors 1000000 Kgs.
E- Production equipment 150 ones.
F- Production sites 4 ones.
G- Stores 2 ones.
In addition to what destroyed during the military operations. The Iraqi side presented all the capabilities necessary to carry out the missions of destruction as soon as possible. Also, Iraq made available a large number of personnel and specialists in the operations of destruction. They took place in al-Muthana Establishment under the supervision of the Special Commission. The Special Commission praised the Iraqi cooperation with it.
The Iraqi efforts lead to prevent the environment pollution and keep the expenses and time of destruction to the minimum. These efforts aim at closing the chemical file. The Special Commission was about to do so. This file was actually closed in June 1995.
5. In August 1995 Iraq handed over all previous chemical programme - related documents. This action was taken by Iraq to show its good will. On the contrary, the Special Commission used these documents to raise doubts about the credibility of the Iraqi declarations and reopened all the files. This happened despite the fact that there was no difference between what was stated in these documents and what was in the Iraqi declarations. The Special Commission intentionally looked over this fact for political purposes unrelated to its technical missions. However Iraq was keen to fully deal with the Special Commission in all relevant aspects. A number of clarifications was presented in relation to suspended issues the Special Commission considered dubious.
The Special Commission asked for the presence of all personnel participating in the past chemical programmes for the purpose of interview and verification. Long discussions were conducted about the suspended issues. However, the Special Commission was still dubious about the Iraqi arguments. It persisted on such policy. It asked for the destruction of the dual use production equipment. Though it previously gave the green light to use such equipment. The Special Commission destroyed (385) production equipment, (90) different analytical equipment and (275) tons of general chemical materials.
6. The number of the chemical teams visited Iraq mounted to (60) ones. They conducted inspections, discussions and interviews with the personnel working in the past chemical programme. The inspections carried out by the Special Commission since 1991 came to a conclusion that there was no proscribed material. A number of surprised and planned inspections was done to sites unrelated to the chemical programme. Such sites included universities, institutes, oil refineries, industrial establishments, offices of the Ministry of Agriculture etc. The inspection teams found nothing that violates the implementation of the Resolution 687.
7. At the beginning of 1997, the Special Commission mentioned in its report that there were (7) suspended issues in the chemical field. Iraq exercised serious efforts to present clarifications related to such issues in the form of exchanged letters. They came as a complementary part to the Iraqi declaration. Two issues (out of seven) were still suspended. They are Vx agent and the special warheads. The Iraqi side asked for a discussion session with the experts of the Special Commission attended by neutral ones to explain the subject. The request was actualized in February 1998.
However, the Special Commission was not satisfied with the arguments and evidence of the Iraqi side. This is because the Special Commission built its satisfaction on unreal information with a view to prolonging and keeping the file open.
8. The suspended issues in the chemical field claimed by the Special Commission had no relationship with the phase of disarmament. They were mentioned only for the purpose of prolonging. Every time Iraq closed a subject, the Special Commission opened another subject already discussed and sorted out. The latest allegation presented by the Special Commission was the appearance of degradation of the Vx agent in samples of the remnant of the warheads which were destroyed by the Iraqi side in summer 1991. These samples were also subjected to analysis in the American Amy's labs. Iraq refused the results concluded. This is due to the fact that Iraq basically does not produce the Vx agent in such a stable way that it can use it in any ammunition.
9. Iraq offered all forms of facilities that made it possible for the Special Commission to monitor all its chemical establishments. This occurred since the monitoring system put in effect in November 1994. The number of such establishments mounted to (80) sites. (35) cameras and (22) air samples sensors were installed in (13) sites. (367) dual-use equipment were labeled with stickers in different sites. They belong to the Military Industrialization Corps, Ministry of Higher Education and the private sectors all over the country. These sites are always subjected to continuos and sudden inspections.
Mid-annual and periodical announcements of all the materials and equipment covered by the monitoring system were presented. The Special Commission acknowledged that the system worked effectively. This acknowledgement was a reflection of the cooperation of the Iraqi side with it.
The Iraqi side was serious and cooperative with the Special Commission with a view to speeding up closing the files. This should eventually lead to the application of para (22) of the SC Resolution (687) to end the sufferings of the Iraqi people. The cooperation and keeness shown by the Iraqi side were meant not to give the Special Commission the chance to present fabricated pretexts in order not to apply the resolution. This came in conformity with the hostile Anglo-American policies against Iraq and the Arab Nation.
The Iraqi chemical programme covered under para ( c)
of the SC Resolution 687 (1991).
The chemical programme - Al-Muthana Complex
The Iraqi Declarations
(Agents, ammunitions, material, sites, equipment)
Destruction due to air raids in 1991 |
Destruction conducted by the UNSCOM 1991-1994 |
Unilateral destruction in 1991. It was verified in 1992 and later on. |
Extra-destruction of dual-use equipment, materials and general analytical equipment |
Joint work programme June 1996. Specification of seven unsettled issues 1997 |
priority issues June 1998 |
Destruction due to air raids in 1991
- More than 1000 tons of chemical precursors.
- 45000 pieces of empty and filled ammunitions (the majoriis 1mm mortar shells).
- 6000 pieces of empty and filled ammunitions (air bombs, 122 mm rockets and artillery shells ).
- 100 pieces of different production equipment.
- 85 stores and buildings.
Notice:
The destroyed items mentioned above were verified by the inspection teams in June 1991 - June 1995.
Destruction Conducted under UNSCOM Supervision 1991-1994
- (690) tons of final Agents .
- (22500) pieces of filled ammunitions (different air bombs and artillery shells).
- (18250) pieces of empty ammunitions (different air bombs and artillery shells.
- (1800000) liters of liquid precusors.
- (1000000) kgs. of solid precusors.
- (150) pieces of production equipment.
- (4) production sites.
- (2) bunkers (stores).
-(30) special warheads (14 filled with Al-cohol and 16 filled with Sarine).
Notice:
The certificates of destruction issued by the Special Commission showed the same figures and items. They were also included in the protocol of handing over Al-Muthana Establishment to the Iraqi side in June 1994.
Unilateral destruction in 1991
It was verified by the Special Commission in 1992
- (29500) pieces of empty ammunitions ( rockets warhead 122 mm, air bombs) .
- (20) special warheads filled with Al cohol.
- (230) tons of different chemical materials.
Notice:
It was verified in April 1992 and reverified during the period August 1995-1998.
Extra destruction of dual - use equipment and
general analytical and chemical equipment
During the period Sept. - October 1997
- (375) pieces of different production equipment.
- (90) pieces of different analytical equipment.
- (81) pieces of analytical equipment handed over to the Special Commission in 1997 (they were returned to Kuwait).
- (275) tons of general chemical materials declared in 1995.
Notice:
Endorsed in Oct. 1997 (certificates of destruction issued by the Special Commission).
Joint work programme in June 1996 and specification
of (seven) suspended issues to be settled in 1997
Counting the special warheads:
- The Vx agents activity (look to the reports of the results of the analysis of the surveillance's samples taken from different special warheads.
- Documents of high-ranking decision.
Notice:
Issues were settled through inspection tasks, technical meetings, written analysis and clarifications during the period Oct. 1996 - 1998. They were handed over to the Special Commission.
Issues of priority still outstanding June 1998
Notice:
Issues were settled on the basis of re-excavation and extraction, analysis, technical meetings and the written clarifications handed over to the Special Commission.
The material balance of the air bombs type (R-400) of the chemical and biological weapons:
No. |
The state of ammunitions |
Quantity |
Verification |
1 |
The total number of the bombs (R-400) manufactured and armed. |
1246 |
All the documents related to the manufactured, armed and tested handed over to the Special Commission Ref |
2 |
The number of the chemical bombs |(R-400) destroyed under the supervision of the Special Commission at Al-Muthana State Establishment |
337 |
Destroyed and verified under the supervision of the Special Commission according to the protocol of handing over Al-Muthana Establishment to the Iraqi side Ref. (28). |
3 |
The number of the empty bombs |
58 |
Destroyed and verified under the supervision of the Special Commission after being verified in Sept. 1991 Ref. (29). |
4 |
The number of the empty and damaged biological bombs (R-400). |
6 |
Verified by the biological group |
5 |
The number of the chemical bombs |
160 |
Verified by the Special Commission in the air base in 1992. |
6 |
The number of the chemical bombs |
240 |
Documents by the dangers of the destruction, which were handed over to the Special Commission Ref. (30). |
7 |
The number of the chemical bombs |
210 |
Documents by the dangers of the destruction. They were handed over to the Special Commission Ref. (31) |
8 |
The number of the chemical bombs |
80 |
Verified by the Special Commission in 1992. |
9 |
The number of the chemical bombs (R400) unilaterally destroyed in the air force's fire field. |
157 |
They were registered in a document handed over to the Special Commission in Nov. 1995. They were verified by the Special Commission (127, 157, 173 - 187) Ref. (32). |
Verified by the Special Commission in addition to (2) extra bombs |
1248 |
|
Among the widely accepted verification documents given there were details of quality control measures showed bodies of rejected bombs (R-400) (107 bodies of bombs out of 298 ones were rejected). The Special Commission asked for further verification. The total number of the bombs (R-400) listed above was identical to what manufactured as fully produced materials (1246) bombs.
Iraq suggested that a final verification shall be conducted to the quantity melted which should be integrated with the tail of the bomb. Therefore the material balance of the tail of the bomb was completed. All the available documents related to the conventional bombs imported by Iraq handed over to the UNSCOM with a letter from the NMD on July 4th 1998.
The Material Balance of the Artillery Shells
155 mm Filled with the Mustard
No. |
The status of Ammunition |
Quantity |
Verification |
1 |
Quantities declared in May |
12634 |
Identical to the actual quantities found and verified by the Special Commission at the end of the war. They were collected at an assembly area as requested by the Special Commission. |
2 |
Quantities destroyed under the supervision of the Special Commission during the period June 1992-1994 |
12792 |
According to the protocol of handing over Al-Muthana Establishment to the Iraqi side (certificate of destruction issued by the Special Commission). |
3 |
Quantities destroyed together with other ones found in the stores which were destroyed during the bombardment (132 shells). |
12924 |
Certificate of the Special Commission of the activities of destruction conducted during the period Feb. 1993- March 1993. |
4 |
In Dec. 1995 a document including an inventory dated 18 Dec. 1990 was found. It included the quantities of the materials found at the different stores of Al-Muthana Establishment. |
13500 |
According to the inventory of the materials and ammunition stored at Al-Muthana Establishment. The documents of inventory were handed over to the Special Commission in Dec. 1995. |
5 |
Quantities of shells 155 mm found during the previous processes of inspection by the Special Commission and the Iraqi side. |
16 |
Verified by field inspection conducted by the Special Commission |
6 |
Discrepancy in the material balance (destruction and documentation). No activity attempted to identify the remaining parts due to the destruction of the war. The problem was not presented in 1996 or 1997 as being among the seven unsettled issues in the chemical file. |
560 |
One of the vehicles loaded with the ammunition was burnt during the transfer. This was according to investigations carried out by the Iraqi side. The traces of the vehicle burnt were still at the place of the incident and were seen by the UNSCOM-248 in July 1998. The quantities missing represents only 4% of the total amount available before the war. |
The Activities of the Vx Agent
No. |
The state of Ammunition |
Quantity |
Verification |
1 |
The Activities of Research anDevelopment. Athe activities in this concern during the period 1985-1990 were declared |
---- |
Verified by the teams of the SC and the discussions according to the report of the Special Commission in 3/6/1998 |
2 |
The Activities of production
|
204 Tons |
The technical report of the agent Vx produced in 1988 was handed over by Iraqi side to the Special Commission in 1996 for the purpose of the calculation of the material balance |
|
|
1-5 Tons |
|
3 |
The armament The Vx was not used as a weapon. No other weapon was filled with the Agent Vx. No Vx in any form was available. |
---- |
The letter of the Director General of Al-Muthana Establishment directed to Military Industrialization Corps. The letter was in relation to the status of the production and the ammunition stored in 5 Jan 1991. The letter was handed over to the Special Commission in Dec. 8th 1995. |
The Material Balance of the Production Equipment
No. |
The state of production Equipment |
Quantity |
Verification |
1 |
All the past chemical programme- related production equipment was declared. The majority of the equipment was destroyed under the supervision of the Special Commission and certain parts of them were lablled. |
317 |
The equipment was declared, verified and destroyed during the period 1994-1997. (Certificate of destruction was issued by the Special Commission). |
2 |
In the second half of 1990 some general - purpose glass ware materials were transferred to Baghdad Electric Bulbs Factory. This was to implement a proposal to establish a workshop to manufacture the glassware materials. These materials were stored in shipping containers. They were not covered by the Security council Resolution. |
|
|
3 |
In the second half of 1996, these containers were again transferred to Baghdad Electric Bulbs Factory. They remained there. |
|
|
4 |
After the processes of inventory of these containers in 1997, which were stored in Baghdad Electric Bulbs Factory, there was only one container which was not opened. It had glassware materials which should be declared according to the revised annex of the Security Council Resolution 715 in 1995. All vessels of 0.05 cubic mm were considered declarable. They were declared in 1997 and destroyed by the (UNSCOM-196) within the period Sept. - Oct. 1997. |
197 |
The clarification of the movement of the shipping containers that had raw materials of the workshop of the glassware materials was handed over to the Special Commission on 4th July 1998. Certificates of destruction issued by the Special Commission covered what mounted to 400 pieces of the equipment of production. |
The Materials Balance of the Special Ammunition
- The production of empty ammunition 31.500
- Import of empty ammunition 161.000
- Ammunition filled with chemical - 130.000
biological agents
-Ammunition discarded during the period 101.080
1983-1988
Empty Filled
- The total amount in 16 Jan. 1991 62.500 28.920
- Destruction during the war 1000 5.000
- Destruction under the supervision 18.250 22.500
of the Special Commission
- Unilateral destruction or discard 28.940 850
- Empty ammunition (Shells 155mm) 15.600 ----
Verified by the Special Commission 63.790 28.350
The total
Empty = 62.500 Empty = 63.790
Filled = 28.920 Filled = 28.350
The balance
Empty = 1290
Filled = 570
The Material Balance of the Special Ammunition