Cantonments
|
|
India’s Ministry of Defense started a drive to rename 58 British-era ‘cantonments,’ preferring to call them ‘military stations,’ according to a statement made by the government to parliament on 24 July 2023. In January 2021, in a major development, the Prime Minister’s Office (PMO) sought views and comments on the abolition of Cantonments in the country, and invited all Cantonment boards to send in their views and comments on abolition of Cantonments. Vivic issues are not resolved properly under MoD’s supervisisin. Civilians living in cantonment areas had long complained of issues regarding different restrictions, and said cantonment boards have failed to resolved them,
The Directorate General of Defence Estates, an inter-services organisation of the Ministry of Defence, directly controls cantonment administration, Cantonment areas were and are primarily meant to accommodate the military population and their installations. Cantonments are different from the Military Stations in that the Military Stations are purely meant for the use and accommodation of the armed forces and these are established under an executive order whereas the Cantonments are areas which comprise of both military and civil population.
Both the cantonments and the military stations are primarily meant for exclusive use of the military personnel in performance of their bona fide duties. The land and facilities built on the land belongs to the government, either because the land was purchased by the government at some point of time or taken on perpetual lease.
The cantonments have its land categorised depending upon their usage as A1, A2, B1, B2, B3, B4 and C categories; A1 being for exclusive use of troops. In military stations, the land is analogous to A1; exclusively for military purposes with no other function envisaged.
The cantonments have a mixed civilian and military population. As laid down in Schedule VII, entry 3, of the Constitution of India, the cantonments have a municipal body for local administration. Besides having the barracks, offices, garages and training areas, etc., which are used only by the troops, the cantonments also have other facilities like schools, hospitals and markets for the troops and their families as also the civil population living within the area. The land is managed by Defence Estates Department of the Government of India. The cantonments, numbering a little over 60, are old establishments. The last of the cantonments was established in 1962.
The civic functions of the cantonments are looked after by Cantonment Boards, with a defence services officer as the President of the Cantonment Board (normally also designated as Station Commander) and an officer from Defence Estates Department as the Chief Executive Officer. The Board has other elected and appointed members as well. The members are elected by the voters who have been living within the cantonment and are registered voters thereof. The Cantonment Board provides services like schools, hospitals, roads, sanitation, arboriculture and permission for renovation of the buildings. In short, it functions as a municipality.
The military stations are also built on the land acquired or leased by the government, but for the sole purpose of use by the military. The Cantonment Act does not apply on military stations and there are no civilian inhabitations therein though some civilian employees may be working there. The military stations came up in more recent times with the expansion of forces, i.e., when new units had to be raised. The administration of a military station is looked after by the military authorities themselves.
There are 61 Cantonments in the country which have been notified under the Cantonments Act, 1924 (succeeded by the Cantonments Act, 2006). The overall municipal administration of the notified Cantonments is the function of the Cantonment Boards which are democratic bodies. The Station Commander of the Cantonment is the ex-officio President of the Board and an officer of the IDES or Defence Estates Organisation is the Chief Executive Officer who is also the Member-Secretary of the Board.
There are four categories of Cantonments which depend on the size of population residing inside a Cantonment. The Cantonments, despite having financial and land constraints especially towards their permissible use for residential and commercial activities, represent the green areas which strive to maintain ecological balance while at the same time providing better civic facilities to the residents.
The word cantonment is derived from the French cantonnement, from cantonner, to quarter; Ger. Ortsunterkunft or Quartier. When troops are distributed in small parties amongst the houses of a town or village, they are said to be in cantonments, which are also called quarters or billets. Formerly this method of providing soldiers with shelter was rarely employed on active service, though the normal method in " winter quarters," or at seasons when active military operations were not in progress. In the field, armies lived as a rule in camp, and when the provision of canvas shelter was impossible in bivouac.
By the late 19th Century,, however, it was unusual, in Europe at any rate, for troops on active service to hamper themselves with the enormous trains of tent wagons that would be required, and cantonments or bivouacs, or a combination of the two had therefore taken the place, in modern warfare, of the old long rectilinear lines of tents that marked the resting-place and generally, too, the order of battle of an 18th-century army. The greater part of an army operating in Europe was accommodated in widespread cantonments, an army corps occupying the villages and farms found within an area of 4 m. by 5 or 6. This allowance of space had been ascertained by experience to be sufficient, not only for comfort, but also for subsistence for one day, provided that the density of the ordinary civil population is not less than 200 persons to the square mile.
Under prevailing conditions there was little danger from such a dissemination of the forces, as each fraction of each army corps is within less than two hours' march of its concentration post. If the troops halted for several days, of course they require either a more densely populated country from which to requisition supplies, or a wider area of cantonments. The difficulty of controlling the troops, when scattered in private houses in parties of six or seven, was the principal objection to this system of cantonments.
But since Napoleon introduced the "war of masses" the only alternative to cantoning the troops was bivouacking, which if prolonged for several nights is more injurious to the well-being of the troops than the slight relaxation of discipline necessitated by the cantonment system, when the latter is well arranged and policed. The troops nearest the enemy, however, which have to be maintained in a state of constant readiness for battle, cannot as a rule afford the time either for dispersing into quarters or for rallying on an alarm, and in western Europe at any rate they were required to bivouac.
Permanent forts, in hot climates, are injurious to the health of the troops, and require permanent garrisons to save them from being occupied by our enemies. They bind the Army to particular localities, which is always objectionable in unsettled and hastily acquired countries. With an efficient force on the left bank of the Indus, troops in an entrenched position, at Peshawur, would easily be reinforced or relieved, in case of need. The cost of a masonry fort, too, would be a very useless outlay of money. The Engineers recommend permanent buildings in preference to temporary ones, as being cheapest in the long run, but that is simply a professional view of the question, and the Engineers are not called upon generally to take any other matter into consideration. All over India the troops suffered from being permanently fixed in places where they ought not to be, simply because the costly palaces that had been built for troops cannot be thrown away.
In India, the term "cantonment" meant more generally a military station or standing camp. The troops lived, not in private houses, but in barracks, huts, forts or occasionally camps. The large cantonments were situated in the neighborhood of the North-Western frontier, of the large cities and of the capitals of important native states. Under Lord Kitchener's redistribution of the Indian army in 1903, the chief cantonments were Rawalpindi, Quetta, Peshawar, Kohat, Bannu, Nowshera, Sialkot, Mian Mir, Umballa, Muttra, Ferozepore, Meerut, Lucknow, Mhow, Jubbulpore, Bojarum, Poona, Secunderabad and Bangalore.
Under the Raj the British Government had the absolute right of occupying any military positions it deemed fit in any of the protected states. It had received the authority of its allies to protect them, and by consequence of this delegation and without further reference to them, it established its cantonments in their principalities. It was essential to the efficiency and safety of the army so cantoned that it should be placed exclusively under British jurisdiction. Just as the ship of war, qui maritimus est exercitus, sails into a foreign port carrying with it its own equipment of laws and disciplinary rules, so the British army, to quote Wheaton, section 95, "stationed in the territory of another state, is exempt from the civil and criminal jurisdiction of the place," and filled the vacuum with its own laws.
The first step taken by the authorities on the occupation of a foreign cantonment was to mark off the land so occupied and define its limits. When this was done, full jurisdiction over all persons and things within the cantonment was asserted without any further reference to the chief. British laws which applied proprio vigore to British subjects or servants in foreign territory of necessity followed the army itself into its cantonment. But the invasion of British jurisdiction went farther. The efficiency of an army depended largely upon the influence of surrounding circumstances. If intoxicating liquors were offered for sale without restriction by the subjects of the Native state living in the cantonment limits ; if the soldiers' accoutrements were bought up by traders; or if sanitary arrangements were wholly neglected, and smallpox and other contagious diseases were left uncared for; the force which occupied a foreign cantonment would become useless for the duties of general defence.
Accordingly, the inability of the British Legislature to pass laws for the subjects of a foreign state was cured by the capacity of the Governor-General in Council to make regulations and establish Courts in the cantonment outside British India. All persons resident, or found, within the cantonment were brought under subjection to British law and the cantonment Courts. If they are not already, as British subjects or servants of the Crown, amenable to the law of British India, the Governor-General in Council notifies that the said British Act is applied by him under the authority of the Foreign Jurisdiction Act and other lawful powers, to the cantonment. He declares the authority of the Courts and the procedure they are to adopt; and thus the whole area of the cantonment, whilst it still retains its character as foreign territory, is occupied alike by British troops and by the laws and Courts which are necessary for its effective occupation.
During the period of occupation, the Native state law and jurisdiction were ousted, and where the ordinary jurisdiction and British laws passed by the Indian Legislature cannot extend proprio vigore to the rest of the cantonment population, the authority of the Governor-General in Council extended them. The sovereignty of the ruler of the country survives, although latent and suppressed for the time being. The chief is not consulted as to the measures which the British Government considers it proper to introduce for the administration of the cantonment, since his consent is implied in his obligations of military defence ; but, when the cantonment is given up, his sovereign rights and powers revive. If the territory had ever been incorporated into British India, its rendition would require an act of the Legislature, and that difficulty is avoided.
|
NEWSLETTER
|
| Join the GlobalSecurity.org mailing list |
|
|
|
