Obama: US Shares Saudi Concerns About Yemen, Syria
September 04, 2015
by Aru Pande
President Barack Obama said Friday that the United States and Saudi Arabia continue to cooperate closely in countering terrorist activity in the Middle East and around the world, including the battle against Islamic State militants.
He said the U.S. shares Saudi Arabia's concerns about Yemen and the need to restore an inclusive, functioning government there, as well as Saudi concerns about the crisis in Syria.
Obama made his remarks before meeting with Saudi King Salman at the White House, in the Arab leader’s first visit to the United States since ascending the throne in January, following the death of King Abdullah.
The president said he and the king planned to discuss implementing the recently negotiated nuclear agreement aimed at curbing Iran's atomic program in return for a relief in sanctions. Saudi Arabia has had reservations about the agreement and views Iran as a regional adversary.
The talks between Obama and the king could not come at a more tumultuous time, as a U.S.-led coalition fights Islamic State militants in Iraq and Syria, and a Saudi-led coalition beats back Iranian-supported Houthi rebels in Yemen.
"This is an important visit at an important time, with the many developments in the region where we have shared interests with Saudi Arabia and with the recent conclusion of the Iran deal and the follow-up of the Camp David summit with Saudi Arabia and our other Gulf partners," Deputy National Security Adviser Ben Rhodes said.
Assurances on Iran
Friday’s meeting is the first since a May 14 summit, during which Obama spent time with Gulf Cooperation Council leaders seeking to assuage any concerns about brokering a nuclear agreement with Iran.
"Many people in the Gulf, in fact the entire Arab world, are concerned about the U.S. position in the Gulf, about the Iran nuclear agreement, about what is happening in terms of Iran’s expanding influence in the Levant, in Iraq, in Yemen," said Anthony Cordesman, a security analyst with the Center for Strategic and International Studies.
Cordesman said dialogue would be critical to building Saudi confidence, particularly in the recently negotiated Iran nuclear agreement.
"They have to be firmly convinced the United States is going to enforce it, is not going to ignore any violations, they will take a hard stand on it," he said.
While noting Saudi Arabia has already expressed support for the deal, Rhodes acknowledged Saudi concerns about Iran getting its hands on some $56 billion in assets because of sanctions relief.
"Iran is in such a significant economic hole that it is our belief that they are likely to spend that money on issues related to improving their economy," Rhodes said. He acknowledged that "we need to ensure that we’re doing everything we can to counter Iran’s destabilizing activities in the region. And there’s always a risk that Iran could spend funds on those nefarious activities."
Building Saudi capabilities
Saudi Arabia’s focus, security analyst Cordesman said, is more on the Iranian buildup of missile force and asymmetric war capabilities “than the possibility they may go nuclear in the future.”
To that end, White House officials said Friday’s discussions would also center on increased security cooperation to build Saudi capacity in dealing with a potential Iranian threat — but not necessarily through the delivery of conventional large-scale systems and heavy weaponry.
"It’s a conversation that we’ve continued under the radar in these working group meetings — really rolling up our sleeves with our experts in departments and agencies to build out a whole range of capabilities in the areas including border security, maritime security, cybersecurity, counterterrorism," Jeff Prescott, the National Security Council’s senior Middle East director, told reporters.
Administration officials say it’s not just concerns about Iran’s activities in the region, but the asymmetric tactics used by extremist groups like the Islamic State that call for "more nimble 21st-century capabilities in areas like [cybersecurity] and maritime and special forces."
Beyond the nuclear deal, Iran’s behavior most likely will also factor into the two leaders' discussion on Iraq.
Former U.S. Ambassador Francis Ricciardone, now director of the Atlantic Council’s Rafik Hariri Center for the Middle East, said Saudi Arabia has a stake in seeing its northern neighbor stabilized.
"I should think the discussion between President Obama and King Salman on Iraq will be very interesting, as to what each side can do to support Prime Minister [Haider] Abadi in holding that country together and strengthening its independence from a hegemonistic influence," Ricciardone said.
Ending the fighting, urging a political solution and addressing a humanitarian crisis are goals both leaders most likely will push for — not just in Iraq and Syria, but also in Saudi Arabia’s southern neighbor, Yemen. There, Saudi airstrikes continue to pound Houthi rebel targets on a regular basis.
The Gulf nation has come under fire for its bombing campaign, which has killed hundreds of Yemenis in strikes hitting civilian targets, including a dairy factory and residential compounds.
The United Nations said more than 2,100 civilians in Yemen were killed in the conflict between March and July, the majority from coalition airstrikes, for which the United States is providing logistics and intelligence support.
Human rights concerns
In a statement, Human Rights Watch’s Middle East director, Sarah Leah Wilson, urged Obama and Salman to “discuss the Saudi-led bombing campaign and agree to end indiscriminate attacks that have killed countless Yemeni civilians."
"The U.S. should recognize that the role it’s playing in military operations in Yemen may also make it responsible for laws-of-war violations by coalition forces," she said.
White House officials said they expected an "expression of concern" during Friday’s talks.
"With respect to Yemen, we have very deep concerns,” Rhodes said. “We are able … to again provide certain types of support to the efforts in Yemen, but also, I think, to be frank, when we believe that more care needs to be taken to avoid civilian casualties. And that will be an ongoing position that we take.”
Human Rights Watch also urged Obama to press Salman on other rights issues, saying the Saudi leader has "largely failed" to improve his country's human rights record during his first seven months in power.
"Under Salman, Saudi Arabia has continued to execute people in record numbers, including nonviolent drug offenders; repressed pro-reform activists and peaceful dissidents; failed to take steps to protect the rights of foreign workers; and maintained its systematic discrimination against women and religious minorities," the organization’s statement said.
|Join the GlobalSecurity.org mailing list|