World: War Against Terrorism Cannot Be Won Without Fully Involving Muslims

World: War Against Terrorism Cannot Be Won Without Fully Involving Muslims

By Jan Jun

British Prime Minister Tony Blair, in a speech on March 21, said he does not see the "war on terror" as a "clash of civilizations" between majority Christian societies and the Muslim world. Rather, he said, it is a "clash about civilization," whose goal is to show people living in Muslim societies the benefits of a modern culture that is open, diverse, and secular. In this context, experts say, the war on terror cannot be won just by strength of arms, better-quality intelligence, or by strict border controls. They stress that the democratic community must involve Muslims on its side to prevail.

LONDON, March 22, 2006 (RFE/RL) -- The September 11 attacks, the Madrid and London bombings, as well as terror strikes in Jordan, Iraq, and countless other spots around the globe show that the war on terror will not be easy.

And it will not be won, experts say, without engaging the world's peaceful Muslim majority.

Peter Neumann, director of the Center for Defense Studies at London's International Political Institute, says a good place for Europeans to start is in their home countries.

"I think it is necessary for Western countries to engage and work with their Muslim communities much more than they have done in the past," he says. "I think that the London bombings last year were a perfect example, because the people who were responsible, were actually born in Britain; they grew up in Britain; they were British citizens."

Neumann explains that with the Muslim population in Europe now totaling some 20 million, the same is true not just for Britain, but for the whole of Europe.

Other observers agree. Lord Rees-Mogg, former editor in chief of "The Times," says the war on terror is a war in which the responsible governments of the world have a straightforward security job, in which they are trying to stop terrorists achieving their objectives. But he adds that there is also another dimension.

"But also, very obviously, I think the war on terror requires establishing, where one can, an open relationship with Muslims," Rees-Mogg says. "I think that is true, because it's a war for the hearts and minds of the Islamic community amongst other things."

How to achieve this crucial aim? Experts broadly agree that political, religious, and community leaders have an important role to play, particularly with young people. They must encourage them to be part of the mainstream community, to identify with the countries where they live, especially if they form large minorities there, such as in France, Britain, Germany, or Spain.

But governments must also listen to the concerns and grievances of the Muslim communities, and help improve their circumstances, say Muslim organizations.

"We believe there are a range of concerns British Muslims have," Muslim Council of Britain spokesman Inayat Bunglawala says. "Not just with Iraq, not just to do with the antiterror measures, but also to do with religious discrimination, with moral issues such as abortion and euthanasia, with social exclusion and underachievement."

Bunglawala says ways to bring Muslims into the mainstream of British life include better education, more sensitive policing, more Muslim members in parliament, and effective measures against social deprivation.

Tackling social deprivation is a major problem, because Muslim immigrants in European countries have tended to concentrate in large ghettos in inner cities. This has made the work of extremist organizations and terrorist recruiters much easier.

"I think that the homegrown terrorism has certainly been accelerated by the growing ghettoification," says Magnus Ranstorp, director of the Center for the Study of Terrorism and Political Violence at the University of St. Andrews in Scotland. "Not just in Britain, but all across Europe. And it's very easy for the recruiters and for those who are manipulating an individual to taking that final step. To find willing recruits that are socially excluded and then marginalized in the society."

Ranstorp adds that the radicalization and recruitment process in these ghettos is of a great concern to the European Union. The task is how to strategically prevent the next Muslim generation from joining up to radical jihadist ideology.

Many experts say the peaceful Muslim majority has to play its part, too. "A lot of it has to be done by Muslim communities themselves," Center for Defense Studies Director Neumann says. "They have to address the extremists within their own communities. There is a limit to what we can do."

Neumann concludes that he has been encouraged by positive response from many Muslim leaders, as well as by the growing backlash within Muslim communities against the terrorists.

Many Muslim leaders now actively promote interfaith and multiethnic programs that foster better understanding and eliminate the separation barrier between Muslim and non-Muslim communities. They say, however, they still need more help to stand up to terrorism and its ideologues.

"We need all the other communities, faith and of no faith, to join hands with us," says Imam Ibrahim Mogra, who is chairman of the Mosque and Community Committee at the Muslim Council of Britain. "This is not a Muslim problem; this is a society problem. We need to take this evil out of our society, and if we can all join hands collectively, I am sure we will enjoy more success."

And Mogra concludes that against such joint effort the forces of hatred and terror cannot prevail.

NEWSLETTER

Join the GlobalSecurity.org mailing list

Homeland Security

World: War Against Terrorism Cannot Be Won Without Fully Involving Muslims