Baku Smooths Over Its Rights Record With A Thick Layer Of Caviar
November 08, 2013
by Robert Coalson
A little caviar and a lot of oil goes a long way.
In recent years, Baku has spent millions of dollars to persuade politicians in Europe and the United States that the oil-rich Caucasus country is a reliable partner -- and to distract them from criticism that the country is authoritarian and fails to respect fundamental human rights.
On October 30, some 600 Washington movers and shakers gathered in the columned halls of the National Building Museum for a five-course dinner and show sponsored by the Azerbaijan-America Alliance. The evening was hosted by alliance Chairman and former U.S. Congressman Dan Burton. The event's 'honorary host committee' included four U.S. senators and 13 members of Congress.
Joshua Noonan, an Azerbaijan analyst for 'The Conway Bulletin' who attended the Washington gala, said 'it was a useful endeavor for them because they had former congressmen and people from D.C.'s media establishment, a lot of the people who lobby for them were there too. It was kind of interesting. It was a great event.'
The lavish event was part of Baku's aggressive strategy of 'caviar diplomacy,' using a broad array of gifts and junkets and other inducements to shift the opinions of policy makers in Azerbaijan's favor.
Former U.S. Ambassador to Azerbaijan Richard Kauzlarich told RFE/RL that 'events like this only highlight the contrast between reality and fiction about Azerbaijan.'
The term 'caviar diplomacy' came to the fore as the title of a May 2012 report by the European Stability Initiative (ESI), a think tank specializing in southeastern Europe and EU enlargement issues.
Gerald Knaus, ESI chairman and an author of the Azerbaijan report, told RFE/RL how the project came about.
'As Azerbaijan's democratic and human rights situation continued to deteriorate, the Council of Europe -- whose role it is to safeguard European standards of democracy and human rights -- became less and less vocal and increasingly silent in its criticism,' Knaus said. 'This concerned elections, political prisoners, general monitoring of Azerbaijan's obligations toward the Council of Europe concerning human rights. So we set out to try to understand and describe how this process of silencing this institution actually operated and how it worked.'
Rebecca Vincent, a human rights activist based in London and a former U.S. diplomat in Baku, says Azerbaijan's public-relations offensive has made her work more difficult.
'From the perspective of a human rights defender, it makes our work very difficult at some of these European institutions, specifically the Council of Europe -- I think it is also going on at the European Union -- when we go to raise concerns about human rights issues, there are very clearly policy makers who have already been swayed the other way,' Vincent says.
The ESI's Knaus adds that Baku's efforts have been 'very aggressive.'
'[Caviar diplomacy] includes a systematic approach to build up friends, to invite people in large numbers. Dozens of members of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE) are invited to Baku by pro-government NGOs or by the government directly every year,' Knaus says. 'It involves a lot of very aggressive lobbying, promising and then offering positions as lobbyists to people who held very important positions in the Council of Europe before, to send a clear signal -- if you are on our side, you might become a well-paid lobbyist.'
The ESI report mentions, among others, former German Christian Democrat lawmaker and former PACE member Eduard Lintner, who was part of a PACE delegation that observed an Azerbaijani referendum in March 2009 that abolished presidential term limits and paved the way for President Aliyev to remain in office indefinitely.
That PACE delegation's report said that the widely criticized referendum 'showed the willingness of the people of Azerbaijan to have greater stability and elements for further democratization.' By the end of 2009, Lintner had left PACE to become chairman of the Society for Promoting German-Azerbaijani Relations (GEFDAB) -- a shadowy organization described as a de facto lobbying group for Baku.
For last month's presidential election in Azerbaijan, in which Aliyev was awarded a third term by a landslide, the GEFDAB sponsored an election-monitoring mission by a Belgian-registered NGO. That mission found the election 'fair, democratic, and transparent.'
Baku's lobbying efforts also seem to extend to the use of front think tanks to shift public opinion. One month before the presidential election, the European Strategic Intelligence And Security Center (ESISC) in Brussels, issued a haphazardly edited report called 'The Republic Of Azerbaijan: A Model Of Good Governance.'
In ungrammatical English, the report praises Azerbaijan's 'stable social welfare,' says women's rights there are 'comparable to that of EU member States,' and notes Baku's 'utter respect of religious minorities.'
The ESISC website notes that it 'produces customized reports, analysis, and … briefings responding exactly to the needs of each client in his or her sector of activity.' The center does not say who the 'client' was in the case of its Azerbaijan report.
Baku's efforts in Europe seemed to bear fruit in January when the PACE rejected -- by a vote of 175 against to 79 in favor -- a tough report prepared by special rapporteur Christoph Strasser identifying 85 political prisoners in Azerbaijan and calling for their release. German MEP Strasser has not been given a visa to enter Azerbaijan since he was named special rapporteur in 2009.
In many ways, Baku's caviar-diplomacy offensive seems tied to last month's presidential election. According to the ESI, which this week issued a report on the election and its aftermath, no fewer than 50 organizations sent election-monitoring teams to Baku.
Forty-nine of them -- mostly obscure and many of them connected with Azerbaijani-funded NGOs such as Lintner's GEFDAB, praised the ballot.
Only the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) criticized the election as undemocratic and not compliant with international standards. Baku has since threatened to sharply curtail its cooperation with the OSCE.
Former U.S. diplomat Vincent does not hesitate to call the actions of many European lawmakers 'unethical.'
'It certainly sends the wrong impression. I think, particularly for policy makers from democratic countries where they enjoy basic rights and fundamental freedoms to be propping up an authoritarian regime that is not respecting the rights of its citizens when their constituents at home have no idea actually what they are up to abroad -- it isn't quite right,' Vincent said.
The work of the Azerbaijan-America Alliance seems to be a geographical extension of Baku's efforts in Europe. Although it is officially an NGO, it was created by Anar Mammadov, an Azerbaijani oligarch and son of Transport Minister Ziya Mammadov. Even a quick look at the group's website shows it strictly follows the Azerbaijani government's positions.
One of the main goals of the alliance is to expand the Azerbaijan Caucus in the U.S. Congress. That group, which was founded in 2004, now has 46 members.
According to the public-interest website Opensecrets.org, which monitors lobbying in Washington, the alliance paid the lobbying firm Fabiani & Company $1.8 million so far in 2013, more than half of its total lobbying revenues. In 2012, the Azerbaijan-America Alliance paid Fabiani $2.4 million and in 2011, $1.8 million.
Analyst Noonan, who attended the recent D.C. gala, says that Baku's public-relations efforts are unlikely to be as influential in the United States as they seem to have been in Europe. Ultimately, he says, Baku must understand that representatives in Congress respond most strongly to their constituents.
'[Baku's public diplomacy] is useful in reaching out to higher-level individuals in D.C., but this lobbying effort will not be a success in the long term if constituents of the representatives are not engaged. Without that engagement, this is just making linkages. You are not going to affect policy at a deep level,' Noonan said.
RFE/RL Azerbaijan correspondent Arife Kazimova contributed to this report from Baku
Copyright (c) 2013. RFE/RL, Inc. Reprinted with the permission of Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, 1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
|Join the GlobalSecurity.org mailing list|